- Hempfield School District
- 2024 HEA Collective Bargaining
HEA Negotiations Update
-
The information contained on this page is intended to provide updates regarding contract negotiations with the Hempfield Education Association (HEA).
Members of the Hempfield Board of School Directors and the Hempfield Education Association (HEA), which represents the teachers and other certificated employees of the district, have been meeting regularly since December 2023 in order to enter into a successful collective bargaining agreement. To date, we have met 11 times and have presented multiple proposals with competitive salaries/financial packages for HEA’s consideration. While progress has been made on a range of subjects important to our bargaining staff, some areas remain unsettled. We are continuing to meet with HEA and are determined to come to an agreement that is beneficial to both our teaching staff as well as the district at large.
Update: 8.30.24
The board and the HEA mutually agreed to keep the specifics of our ongoing contract negotiations confidential. Unfortunately, HEA has chosen to share details online that are false.
We want to clarify that both sides participated in a discussion Thursday evening. During this session, the Board team responded to the latest proposal from HEA. After the discussion, the board team requested up to 30 minutes to finalize a prepared financial package based on the conversation surrounding HEA’s latest proposal. However, HEA declined to allow the board the necessary time to finalize this important task, opting instead to end the session early.
We are disappointed that HEA was unwilling to wait and receive another financial package, which could have furthered our progress. Despite this setback, we remain committed to reaching a fair and equitable agreement.
Dates have been set for the next negotiation session, and we hope to continue our work towards a resolution at that time.
HEA Collective Bargaining Agreement
-
Salary Matrix
A teacher salary matrix is a structured table that determines salaries based on years of experience and educational qualifications. It consists of rows (“steps”) for experience levels and columns for degrees or certifications. Teachers move through the matrix as they gain more experience or higher qualifications, with each cell representing a specific salary amount.
Row/step movement happens annually at the start of the school year. There are 2 opportunities annually for teachers to move columns based on credits earned. Teachers earn credits to move columns by completing college courses. The District reimburses teachers for tuition costs for up to 12 credits for those pursuing Instructional II certification or 9 credits for all others.
-
Step Movement
Understanding What A “Step” Is
A “step” is used to determine a teacher’s salary based on their years of service and level of education. Teachers advance in salary by completing more years in service or acquiring more credits and/or educational degrees.
The two charts below illustrate this point:
The first example would represent a teacher who had one year of experience (and was either bachelor’s degree or bachelor’s degree plus 30 credits) in 2022-23 and moved to step 2 (2 years of experience) in 2023-24 – that particular case, the increases were 8.80% (Bachelors) and 7.67% (Bachelors + 30). The second example follows the same logic but is based on a teacher with significantly more experience in the position.
The current HEA contract consists of fourteen (14) steps, meaning it takes 14 years to get to the top of the salary matrix. The average number of steps in Lancaster County is 16.
-
Column Movement
Understanding Column Movement
A salary matrix column designates the educational level attained by a teacher. At Hempfield, columns begin with bachelor’s degree and end with a doctorate degree. Teachers advance in salary by acquiring more credits and/or educational degrees.
The chart below illustrates this point:
Example of a teacher who moved columns at the beginning of a school year.
-
HEA Matrices (19-20 through 23-24)
The average salary increase in each year of the current contract is 2.8%
-
Increase to Salary Matrix
During contract negotiations, one of the highest priority items is the increase to the salary matrix. This is done by calculating the total salary of the bargaining unit for the last year of the agreement and increasing the total cost of salary by a percentage. This does not mean that every employee receives the same percentage increase but represents the average employee salary increase.
The average salary increase in the current collective bargaining agreement (2019-2024) was 2.8%. While this percentage was lower than many in the county, the average Hempfield teacher salary was still among the highest.
-
Benefits
In addition to salary, the district provides HEA with a comprehensive benefits package that includes:
-
- Medical Insurance
- Dental Insurance
- Vision and Hearing reimbursement plan
- PSERS (retirement)
- Tuition Reimbursement
- Sick Days
- Personal Days
- Emergency Days
- Income Protection (covers absences due to illness/injury)
- Life Insurance
- Educational Sabbaticals
-
-
PSERS (Public School Employees' Retirement System)
PSERS provides teachers with a stable pension income, health benefits, potential cost-of-living adjustments, disability benefits, survivor benefits, service credits, and options for loans or withdrawals. These benefits offer financial security and support throughout retirement.
The District contributes to PSERS for each eligible employee at a rate determined by the state who reimburses the District for 50% of its contributions. The rate for 2024-2025 is 33.90%, which means that the District contributes 16.95% on all wages earned. As the salary matrix increases the total salary for the bargaining unit annually, the PSERS contributions increase proportionately.
PSERS rates, which are controlled by the state, have increased significantly over the last 10 years and are projected to continue to rise. The current projections for 2031-32 is 38.26%.
-
Financial Considerations
In addition to the teacher’s contract, the District faces rising expenditures annually due to many factors:
-
- Investment in repair, maintenance and potential expansion to district facilities
- Increased salaries for all employees (support staff and administrators)
- Increased cost of healthcare
- Increased cost of student transportation
- Increased Special Education costs
- Increased debt service payments
The attached financial update provides additional information relevant to the District’s budget and ability to increase teacher wages.
-
-
Taxing Authority
The Act 1 Index is determined annually by the state and is used to determine the maximum tax increase that the school district may levy.
-
Feasibility Study
The district recently completed a feasibility study of all district buildings. The study highlighted significant repairs needed in nearly every district facility.
We have recently engaged with an architect to begin working on a solution for the high school. The study projected repair costs to be in excess of $200M.
The School Board has been making efforts to put funds aside in capital reserve to begin to address the issues that exist in our buildings. In addition, there is a commitment to preserving a portion of the tax increase for 2024-25 and the coming years for future debt payments related to the work on our buildings.
-
Work to Rule
On Aug. 21, we were informed that "The association has voted to start the year off operating as they would any school year."
Work to rule is when teachers choose to abide by the absolute minimum required of their existing collective bargaining agreement.
It is important to understand that our teaching staff is being paid during ongoing negotiations. The Board of School Directors passed a resolution invoking “status quo” conditions, which means that teachers will continue to receive salary and benefits in accordance with the final year of the existing contract.
Media Inquiries
-
LNP Request for Info - Contract Negotiations 8/16/24
On Thursday, Aug. 15, LNP reporter Ashley Stalnecker sent questions to the Hempfield School Board President, providing “an opportunity to offer the board’s perspective on an upcoming article (she) will be writing to update readers to the ongoing contract negotiations at Hempfield School District.” She shared she had already spoken with the HEA President. The Board met her Aug. 16 noon deadline with the following responses.
The message below is from the Hempfield School Board Directors.
As we begin a new school year, we understand there are concerns regarding the delay in approving the teacher contract. Our goal continues to be to provide a fair and equitable contract for our professional staff while balancing the many needs throughout the district.
As in past years, we remain committed to providing our teachers with the resources and support needed to begin the school year smoothly. This includes maintaining all existing benefits and conditions of employment until a new contract is settled. While we are disappointed the contract has not been finalized, we are actively engaging in discussions with the teachers' union to address outstanding issues.
The Board has provided publicly available, factual information about the collective bargaining agreement that ended on June 30, 2024.
Several factors could prevent a contract from being settled. However, the Board and HEA have mutually agreed not to share specifics about negotiations.
We appreciate the patience and understanding of our community as we work through these negotiations.
In terms of your questions:
- What is causing a continued delay in finalizing a contract? Could you provide an example for taxpayers on what is a typical factor in contract negotiations that cause a delay?
- Several factors could prevent a contract from being settled. However, the Board and HEA have mutually agreed not to share specifics about negotiations.
- Why did the district post updates on the contract negotiations on its website?
- The Board has provided publicly available, factual information about the collective bargaining agreement that ended on June 30, 2024. The Board and HEA have mutually agreed not to share specifics about negotiations.
- What is your response to community concerns regarding the delayed contract?
- As in past years, we remain committed to providing our teachers with the resources and support needed to begin the school year smoothly. This includes maintaining all existing benefits and conditions of employment until a new contract is settled. While we are disappointed the contract has not been finalized, we are actively engaging in discussions with the teachers' union to address outstanding issues.
- How does the district plan to make adjustments to continue practices that teachers may no longer volunteer for if a "work to rule" is invoked by the HEA?
- We know our teachers will do what is needed for our students during their workday.
- How would you describe the current relationship between district administration, the board and the union?
- The board and the administration are committed to working with HEA to deliver a high-quality education for all students.
- The relationship between the board and the union is challenged right now due to competing priorities and different viewpoints regarding the contract.
- When do you anticipate that a contract will be finalized?
- We are hopeful the contract will be resolved as quickly as possible.
- When the contract is finalized, will teachers be paid retroactively to compensate for any raise they would be entitled to in the 2024-25 school year according to the new contract?
- The Board and HEA have mutually agreed not to share specifics about negotiations.